Chapter 1: The Paradox of Uniqueness

In the words of Paul Simon, “Over the mountain, down in the valley, lives a former talk-show host. Everybody knows his name. He says there’s no doubt about it. It was the myth of fingerprints. I’ve seen them all, and man, they’re all the same.” This sentiment encapsulates a profound truth: while we perceive ourselves as distinct individuals, we often find that we are merely echoes of those who have come before us. Some may find solace in this realization, believing that our shared struggles bind us as a collective. However, I find this notion to be deeply disheartening.

Growing up in a hopeful America, I was raised in an environment where aspirations seemed limitless. Our parents, shaped by the sacrifices of those who endured the Great Depression, believed they could reshape the world. They ventured forth to forge their paths, leaving us to revel in the spoils of their hard work: Atari consoles, Pop-Tarts, and HBO.

While it's understandable that corporations like Kellogg’s, Huffy, and Mattel didn't design our futures, we might be forgiven for expecting more from life. It's not merely about the absence of futuristic conveniences like personal robots or flying cars; it's the glaring lack of genuine progress in equality, opportunity, and security. Instead, we find ourselves as a nation of disillusioned individuals, yearning for a touch of kindness.

In the film The Big Short, Mark Baum poignantly states, “We live in an era of fraud in America. Not just in banking, but in government, education, religion, food, and even baseball. What bothers me isn’t that fraud is not nice. Or that fraud is mean. For fifteen thousand years, fraud and shortsighted thinking have never, ever worked. Not once.” This observation highlights how we often forget the lessons of history, repeating cycles of folly and deception that have plagued humanity.

Amidst our overwhelming confidence in the uniqueness of our current era, we overlook the recurring patterns of human behavior. History has moments where various forces converge, creating a tempest of chaos that feels both unavoidable and defining. Yet, in retrospect, paths forward often reveal themselves with clarity.

The myth of American exceptionalism, rooted in our colonial beginnings and exemplified by Thomas Paine’s influential pamphlet, Common Sense, has persisted through the ages. This document, second only to the Bible in its readership, galvanized support for independence from Britain.

America’s ability to craft its own identity is perhaps one of its most significant contributions to human society. Critics argue that we lack a genuine culture, reducing ourselves to a society driven by consumption. Yet, daily, countless individuals worldwide aspire to make America their home, whether through legal means or otherwise.

Regardless of its flaws, America remains a beacon of dreams, where aspiring actors, athletes, scientists, and writers come to test their mettle against the world. It is viewed as the heart of unrestrained capitalism and the epicenter of narrative branding. While some may dismiss it as just another place, for many, it embodies the field of dreams.

Chapter 2: The Rise and Fall of Empires

Empires have risen and fallen throughout history. Greece, once a dominant force, now struggles for financial stability. Italy, Britain, Spain, France, and the Dutch have all seen their glory days fade into quaint remembrances of past prowess.

Historically, empires have averaged a lifespan of roughly 250 years, often succumbing to internal decay or external conquest. The belief that America can defy this pattern stems from a sense of exceptionalism that some may hold dear.

However, we do possess unique attributes: our geographical isolation, vast untapped land, abundant natural resources, and unparalleled military strength. If one were to assess history objectively, it might seem that our time of dominance is nearing its end. Yet, like a dying star, we may not simply fade; a supernova might be our ultimate fate.

This contemplation leads me to ponder whether any of this is truly worth fighting for. As I age, my certainty in my ability to influence the future wanes. How exceptional is America, really? What distinguishes me from those who have come before? These questions often remain unanswered, leading me to the realization that individual actions may not drastically alter the course of history.

While individuals can catalyze change, we seldom have control over what ignites significant transformations. Our best efforts may feel like drops in an ocean, tipping the scales only slightly.

I don't subscribe to notions of fate or destiny; life often appears chaotic, lacking discernible patterns. Observing a colony of ants might suggest intention on a larger scale, yet following an individual ant reveals a life that seems inconsequential.

At its zenith, leaders of Rome likely could not fathom a time when their empire would collapse. They could not foresee Italy's transformation into a small nation known for cuisine and fashion. Such a powerful entity's downfall would have seemed unimaginable.

David Sedaris reflects on his fascination with taxidermy through a visit to a New York shop, describing how customers are drawn to the allure of the unique yet often make choices that lead to harm. It serves as a reminder that our pride in individuality may mask a deeper truth: when the dust settles, it often comes down to fingerprints.

If none of us are particularly extraordinary, and America is no more exceptional than past empires, perhaps the focus should shift to making the best of our circumstances. We should strive to be kind, patient, and empathetic, both to others and ourselves, while acknowledging our imperfections.

Breathe.

If you appreciate this reflection, consider following more insights from David Todd McCarty. For those not yet subscribed to Medium, sign up to access his writings and thousands of other captivating pieces. Follow David Todd McCarty on Mastodon for more updates.