Mass Extinction of Ediacaran Life: Lessons for Today
Written on
Chapter 1: Understanding Mass Extinctions
Continuing from our previous discussion in the Forgotten Origins series, we delve into the late Ediacaran mass extinction, an event that echoes in today's ecological challenges.
The prevailing view on mass extinctions suggests that we are currently experiencing an Anthropocene extinction, marking Earth’s sixth mass extinction. Most scientific literature dates the first mass extinction to the Ordovician period, around 445 million years ago. However, this perspective may overlook paleontological evidence from the Late Ediacaran, raising questions about our historical accounting.
Mass extinctions are characterized by the swift loss of a significant number of species within the biosphere. Such catastrophic events are documented in the fossil record, creating boundaries between distinct geological epochs. One of the most significant boundaries recognized by early geologists was the shift from the Precambrian to the Cambrian period, often referred to as the demarcation between the Proterozoic and Paleozoic eras. In Darwin’s era, the fossil record seemed to stop abruptly at 541 million years ago with the onset of the Cambrian. This gave the impression of an instantaneous leap from billions of years of lifelessness to a sudden explosion of life.
Recent discoveries reveal that the Cambrian explosion followed a long history of Ediacaran life. While mass extinctions can seem overwhelmingly negative due to the species lost, they do not signify total extinction; life invariably adapts and evolves thereafter. Historically, the periods following mass extinctions have seen the emergence of new species that occupy the ecological niches left vacant by the die-offs.
Section 1.1: The Cambrian Explosion
The Cambrian explosion marks a remarkable increase in biodiversity following a substantial die-off. The Ediacaran lifeforms, which thrived in the shallow seas, were largely replaced by a plethora of new species during this time. In a brief span at the dawn of the Cambrian, nearly all contemporary animal phyla originated, while the Ediacaran biota faded into oblivion.
The extensive fossil records of Ediacaran organisms highlight a rich biosphere filled with soft-bodied life. Although some fossil assemblages are exceptionally well-preserved, linking them to modern phyla remains challenging. Nevertheless, it is evident that life flourished in Earth’s oceans for nearly 40 million years before the Cambrian explosion.
The evolution during the Ediacaran period led to crucial advancements in animal life, including mobility, sexual reproduction, and complex digestive systems. These developments laid the groundwork for the emergence of more intricate organisms as life transitioned into the Cambrian.
Section 1.2: Transitioning to New Life Forms
The boundary between the Precambrian and Cambrian signifies a shift from soft-bodied organisms to complex animals with hard body parts. This transition was swift, and fossils of Ediacaran species are notably absent in Cambrian layers. The ecosystems of the Ediacaran became extinct, supplanted by the hard-shelled predators of the Cambrian era, indicating a mass extinction event.
One common hypothesis is that the new Cambrian organisms were agile predators equipped with protective shells and insatiable appetites. Their speed gave them a distinct advantage over the slower Ediacaran creatures, leading to their extinction. While this theory is plausible, it may not tell the whole story.
Chapter 2: The Causes of the Ediacaran Extinction
Unraveling the causes of the late Ediacaran extinction remains a complex puzzle, yet researchers are actively investigating. In 2018, a study proposed that the Ediacaran Period ended due to anoxic conditions in Earth's oceans. By analyzing uranium isotope variations in limestone samples from three prominent Ediacaran sites in China, scientists identified an episode of extreme anoxia coinciding with the disappearance of Ediacaran biota. However, this data reflects conditions at one location and may not represent global circumstances.
Another theory suggests that early Cambrian organisms, likely burrowers and grazers, disrupted the Ediacaran lifestyle. Their activities could have severely impacted food chains and destroyed existing seabed ecosystems. Observations of decreasing species diversity in the last several million years of the Ediacaran support this notion of a gradual extinction rather than a sudden catastrophic event.
The evidence increasingly supports the idea that competition among species triggered the late Ediacaran mass extinction. This scenario serves as a partial parallel to the ongoing Anthropocene extinction, where Homo sapiens has come to dominate Earth’s ecosystems. With a global population exceeding eight billion, the strain on natural resources and the environment is palpable. Mass extinctions can occur without dramatic events like asteroid impacts; they can arise simply from biotic replacement, as seen in the current Anthropocene context.
The first video explores the Ediacara biota and their role in the first mass extinction of complex life forms, providing insights into this crucial transition period.
The second video investigates whether competition among species led to the extinction of Earth's earliest animals, shedding light on the dynamics of the Ediacaran-Cambrian transition.
Sources:
- What caused the mass extinction of Earth’s first animals? Unraveling mystery of the Ediacaran-Cambrian transition (Source Science Daily)
- Earth’s First Mass Extinction Was Caused by The Emergence of Animals, Scientists Say (by Peter Dockrill; Science Alert)
- Mass Extinctions: The Case of the Vanishing Ediacarans (by Andrew Alden; KQED)
- Biotic replacement and mass extinction of the Ediacara biota (by Simon A. F. Darroch et al.; The Royal Society)